Private Law

Private Law

An Analysis of the Objective and Subjective Approaches to the Concept of Investment under the ICSID Convention

Document Type : Research Article

Authors
1 Department of Law, Khomeinishahr., Islamic Azad University, Khomeinishahr, Iran
2 Department of Law, Kho.C., Islamic Azad University, Khomeinishahr, Iran
10.22059/jolt.2026.411869.1007460
Abstract
The existence of an “investment” is a fundamental jurisdictional requirement (ratione materiae) for accessing arbitration under the ICSID Convention. Pursuant to Article 25, the absence of such an investment precludes the Centre’s jurisdiction. Current doctrine and jurisprudence present two competing frameworks for determining this requirement: the objective approach and the subjective approach. While the Convention lacks an explicit definition of “investment,” causing significant debate, this study employs a doctrinal, library-based research method to analyze the legal foundations of these divergent approaches. The research addresses why ICSID arbitral tribunals have inconsistently applied these theories in practice. It examines the tension between the subjective approach, which prioritizes party consent within investment agreements, and the objective approach, which relies on external criteria (such as the Salini test) to circumscribe jurisdiction. The study ultimately seeks to clarify the normative reasoning behind the prevailing judicial trends in international investment arbitration.
Keywords
Subjects

ابراهیمی، سید نصرالله و سلطان‌زاده، سجاد (1393). مفهوم سرمایه‌گذاری در رویة داوری مرکز حل‌‌و‌فصل اختلافات سرمایه‌گذاری خارجی (ایکسید). مجلة حقوقی بین‌المللی، 31(50)، 77 ـ 108.
السان، مصطفی و نگین‌تاجی، زریر (1402). چالش‌های داوری سرمایه‌گذاری خارجی با تأکید بر نظام حقوقی ایران. پژوهش‌های حقوقی، 22(55)، 115 ـ 139.
زمانی، سید قاسم و درون‌پرور، امیر (1394). پویایی مفهوم «سرمایه‌گذاری» در پرتو متدولوژی‌های احراز صلاحیت ایکسید. دیدگاه‌های حقوق قضایی، 20(69)، 97 ـ 124.
عبداللهی، محمدجواد و کریمی، محمد (1403). تحلیلی بر معیار «کمک به توسعة اقتصادی دولت میزبان» برای تحقق مفهوم قراردادهای سرمایه‌گذاری تحت کنوانسیون داوری ایکسید. دانشنامة حقوق اقتصادی، 31(26)، 146 ـ 161.
ـــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــ (1404). تحلیلی بر معیار ریسک در قراردادهای سرمایه‌گذاری تحت کنوانسیون داوری ایکسید. حقوق خصوصی، 22(1)، 55 ـ 67.
ــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــ (1404). لکس مرکاتوریا: نظام حقوقی بازارمحور. پژوهش‌های حقوق اقتصادی و تجاری، 3(4)، 291 ـ 318.
قوامی‌پور سرشکه، محدثه و محمودی، امیررضا (1404). شناسایی حقوق مالکیت فکری به عنوان سرمایه‌گذاری در پرتو حقوق بین‌المللی سرمایه‌گذاری. دانشنامة حقوق اقتصادی، 27(32)، 53 ـ 72.
نظام‌مالکی، جعفر (1403). واکاوی مفهوم سرمایه در حقوق بین‌الملل سرمایه‌گذاری با تأکید بر اموال فکری (مطالعة تطبیقی رویکرد جهان‌شمول و ایران). مطالعات حقوق تطبیقی معاصر، 15(37)، 287 ـ 321.
مجتهدی، محمدرضا (1390). درآمدی بر حقوق حل‌وفصل اختلافات سرمایه‌گذاری بین‌المللی بر مبنای کنوانسیون «داوری ایکسید». مطالعات حقوق تطبیقی معاصر، 2(3)، 175 ـ 199.
Abdollahi, M. J. & Karimi, M. (2023). An analysis of the criterion of “contribution to the economic development of the host state” for realizing the concept of investment contracts under the ICSID Arbitration Convention. Encyclopedia of Economic Law, 31(26), 146-161. (in Persian)
------------------------------------ (2025). An Analysis of the Risk Criteria in Investment Contracts under the ICSID Arbitration Convention. Private Law, 22(1), 55-67. (in Persian)
Artamonova, I. (2025). New Developments in International Investment Agreements as Regards Foreign Investors' Obligations In Search of a More Balanced Approach, Germany. Logos Verlag Berlin.
Bekker, P. H., Dolzer, R., & Waibel, M. (Eds.). (2010). Making transnational law work in the global economy: essays in honour of Detlev Vagts. Cambridge University Press.
Boddicker, J. (2010). Whose Dictionary Controls?: Recent Challenges to the Term ‘Investment’ in ICSID Arbitration. American University International Law Review, 25(5).
Calboli, I. & de Werra, J. (2025). Research Handbook on Intellectual Property Licensing, Second Edition. USA: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
Capaldo, G. Z. (Ed.). (2022). The Global Community Yearbook of International Law and Jurisprudence 2020. Oxford University Press.
Chen, H. (2025). China’s Practice in International Investment Law. Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore.
Collins, D. & Allen Geist, M. (2023). Research Handbook on Digital Trade. UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
Demİrkol, B. (2015). The Notion of ‘Investment’ in International Investment Law. The Turkish Commercial Law Review, 1(1), 41-50.
Ebrahimi, S. N. & Soltanzadeh, S. (2014). The Concept of Investment in Arbitration Precedent of the International Center for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID). International Law Review, 31(50), 77-108. (in Persian).
 Elsan, Mostafa, Negintaji, Zarir (2023), Challenges of Foreign Investment Arbitration with Emphasis on The Iranian Legal System, Journal of Legal Research, 22 (55 ),  115-139. (in Persian).
Exelbert, J. M. (2016). Consistently inconsistent: What is a qualifying investment under Article 25 of the ICSID Convention and why the debate must end. Fordham L. Rev., 85, 1243.
Fenwick, M. & Wrbka, S. (2016). Flexibility in Modern Business Law: A Comparative Assessment. Japan: Springer.
Freedom Qumba, M. (2019). South Africa's move away from international investor-state dispute: a breakthrough or bad omen for investment in the developing world?. De Jure Law Journal, 52(1), 358-379.
Garcia-Bolivar, O. E. (2010). Protected Investments and Protected Investors: The Outer Limits of ICSID's Reach. Trade Law & Development, 2(1), 145.
Ghavami pour sereshkeh, Mohadeseh,  mahmoudi, Amirreza (2025), Recognition of intellectual property rights as investment in light of international investment law, Encyclopedia of Economic Law Journal, 32( 27), 53-72. (in Persian).
Herdegen, M. (2024). Principles of International Economic Law. UK: Oxford University Press.
Makedon Sudborough, C. (2023). Mediating Sovereign Debt Disputes, Switzerland. Springer International Publishing.
Malik, M. (2009). Bulletin #1 Definition of Investment in International Investment Agreements. The International Institute for Sustainable Development, 1-19.
Moens, G. (2003). International Trade and Business Law Annual.UK: Cavendish Pub. Vol. 8.
Mojtahedi, Mohammad Reza (2011). An Introduction to Law Settlement of Disputes on International Investments, as Set forth at " ICSID Convention", Contemporary Comparative Legal Studies,  2 ( 3) , 175-199. . (in Persian).
Motamedi, Amin, Askari, Pouria (2025). Deceptively Simple: Explanation of the Concept of Intellectual Investment in Foreign Investment Law, With an Emphasis on the ICSID Arbitration Procedure, International Law Review, 42 (78), 9-34. . (in Persian).
Musurmanov, I. U. (2013). The implications of'Romak v Uzbekistan'for defining the concept of investment. Australian International Law Journal, 20, 105-129.
Nezamolmolki, Jafar(2024). An Analysis of the Concept of Investment in International Investment Law with Emphasis on Intellectual Property (A Comparative Study of the Universal Approach and Iran), Contemporary Comprative Legal Studies, 15(37), 287-321. (in Persian).
Ngobeni, L. (2020). Do the SALINI Criteria apply to the Definition of an Investment provided in Annex 1 of the 2006 and 2016 SADC Protocol on Finance and Investment? An Assessment. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal/ Potchefstroomse Elektroniese Regsblad, 23(1).
Okpe, F. O. (2017). The definition of investment and the ICSID convention: matters arising under the Nigerian investment promotion act and international investment law. Journal of Sustainable Development Law and Policy (The), 8(2), 133-154.
Petsche, M. (2023). The Meaning of Investment under Art 25 ICSID Convention, 56–89.
-------------- (2024). The Concept of Investment in ICSID Arbitration. Oxford University Press.
Raman (2020). Nta Ugc Net/Set/Jrf. Management, 1-422.
Ramić, A. & Brodlija, F. (2025). International Investment Law and Dispute Resolution in the Western Balkans Regional Prospects for a European Future. Brill.
Sattorova, M. (2012). Defining investment under the ICSID convention and BITs: of ordinary meaning, telos, and beyond. Asian Journal of International Law, 2(2), 267-290.
Schacherer, S. (2021). Sustainable development in EU foreign investment law. Brill. Vol. 19.
Segger, M. C. C., Gleason, T., & Stephenson, S. (Eds.). (2025). Research Handbook on Investment Law and Sustainable Development. Edward Elgar Publishing.
Sinclair, A., Reinisch, A., H., Schreuer, C., Malintoppi, L., & W. Schill, S. (2025). Schreuer's Commentary on the ICSID Convention A Commentary on the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes Between States and Nationals of Other States. UK: Cambridge University Press.
Viñuales, J. & Waibel, M. (2021). ICSID Reports. USA: Cambridge University Press. Vol. 19.
Weiler, T. (2005). International Investment Law and Arbitration: Leading Cases from the ICSID, Nafta, Bilateral Treaties and Customary International Law, TDM 5, in Book Reviews & Related Materials.
Zamani, S. G. & Darounparvar, A. (2023). The Dynamics of the Concept of "Investment" in Light of Ixed Qualification Methodologies. The Quarterly Journal of Judicial Law Views, 20(69), 97-124. (in Persian).