An inquiry on the rule of limitation in court proceedings in scope of object of claim

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor in Faculty of Law¸ University of Tehran

2 Ph.D Student of Private Law in Tehran University Kish International Campus

Abstract

Undoubtedly, one of the most important concerns in lodging a petition and initiating a lawsuit is the scope of hearing within the limitations of the petition. Legitimacy, nature of rule and its limits seem to be important in order to clarify based on what criteria the scope of hearing is determined or limited or forbidden. The scope of hearing within the limitations of the petition can be inferred from the spirit and letter of Civil Procedure and some jurisprudential guidelines. The findings show that observance of this imperative procedural rule is a must in all hearing stages and is subject to sanction. There are some exceptions to the subject of the scope of hearing within the limitations of the petition but, these exceptions must be interpreted restrictively in favor of observance of this rule and other legal principles and rules including the principle of Impartiality of Judges. The present descriptive-analytical research examines this rule and the limitations of the court’s authority to add parts to or omit parts of the petition and the lawsuit on the basis of legal principles and jurisprudential guidelines and also it aims to provide some suggestions in this regard.

Keywords

References

Ameli, Zeinoddin (1989). Rozatolbahiah Fi Sharhe Allomato Dameshgiah, By Seyed Mohammad Kalantar, Vol. 3, Qom, Davari Publications. (in Arabic)
American Law Institute UNIDROIT (2004). Principles of Transnational Civil Procedure, American.
Andrew tettenborn¸ MA¸ LLB (2002). The law of Restitution in England and Ireland¸ London, Third edition.
Ansari, Morteza (1994). Adjudication and Testimony, Researcher of Research Team of Sheikh Ansari Commemoration Congress, Qom, Sheikh Ansari Publications. (in Arabic)
Asadi, Behnam (2018). A Survey of Issues Related to Relief Sought, Ghanounyar Quarterly, Jahad Daneshgahi Scientific Information Center, Course 2, No 7, pp. 483-491. (in Persain)
Bahrami, Bahram (2009). Civil Procedure III & Iv, Tehran, Negah Bayeneh Publications. (in Persain)
Bahrami, Mohammadkazem (2015). Judgment Ethics & Manners, Qom, Maarif Publications. (in Persain)
Bariklo, Alireza (2017). Civil Liability: Extra-Contractual Obligations, Tehran, Mizan Publications. (in Persain)
Boroujerdi, Aghahossein (2008). Jami Ahadis Shiah, Vol. 30, Tehran, Farhang Sabz Publications. (in Arabic)
Daneshpajouh, Mostafa (2011). An Introduction to Law with an Emphasis on Iranian and Islamic Law, Tehran, Samt Publications. (in Persain)
Eftekhar-M ahromi, Goudarz & Elsan, Mostafa (2017). Civil Procedure, Vol. 2, Tehran, Mizan Publications. (in Persain)
Ejtehadi, Abbas et al. (1995). Selected Writs of Civil Courts, Tehran, Mizan Publications. (in Persain)
Emami, Seyed Hassan (1961). Civil Law, Vol. 1, Tehran, Eslamieh Publication. (in Persain)
G`erad CORNU et Jean Foyer (1996). procedure civile, puf, 3ed.
Ghamami, Majid (2015). Principles of Procedure in terms of Procedure: On the Civil Procedure of France, Vol. 2, Tehran, Enteshar Publications. (in Persain)
Ghamami, Majid & Mohseni, Hassan (2013). Transnational Civil Procedure, Tehran, Enteshar Publications. (in Persain)
Ghasemzadeh, Seyed Morteza (2010). Principles of Contracts and Obligations, Tehran, Dadgostar Publications. (in Persain)
Geoff, Monahan; Susan Carr-Gregg; Essential Contract Law; published (2001) . By Cavendish publishing Australia¸ Tehran¸ cheragh danesh¸ 1392.
Hayati, Aliabbas (2018). Civil Procedure in Contemporary Legal Order, Tehran, Mizan Publications. (in Persain)
Houshmand, Mehrdad (2018). Questions about Civil Procedure, Tehran, Jangal Publications. (in Persain)
Hunt, Martin (1934). A level and level law, By: Mohamad-taghi rafee, Tehran, Majd.
Iranshahi, Alireza (2017). Civil Procedure, Tehran, Payame Noor University Publications. (in Persain)
Jafari-Langroudi, Mohammad-Jafar (2004). An Introduction to Law, Tehran, Ganj-e Danesh Publications. (in Persain)
Katouzian, Naser (2002). An Introduction to Law , Tehran, Enteshar Publications. (in Persain)
Katouzian, Naser (2010). Specified Contracts, Vol. 4, Tehran, Enteshar Publications. (in Persain)
Khakbaz, Mohammad (2017). Commutative Justice and Rule of Balance of Rights and Obligations, Vol. 1, Nature, Applications and Instances, Tehran, Majd Publications. (in Persain)
Khakbaz, Mohammad (2019). A Treatise on Penalty Clause, Tehran, Majd Publication. (in Persain)
Khakbaz, Mohammad (2020). Justice and Equity in Judicial Dedications: Selected Decisions and their Analysis, Vol. 1, Tehran, Jangal Publications. (in Persain)
Khaleghian, Javad; Mohammadi, Omid, Elaheh (2016). Jurisdiction of Family Court, Tehran, Andisheh Sabz Novin Publications. (in Persain)
Mamaghani, Mohamam-Hassan (1971). Ghayatolamal Fi Sharholmakasib, Vol. 3, Qom, Majmaolzakhair aleslamiah Publications. (in Arabic)
Maraghi, Seyed Abdolfatah (1996). Alanavinolfeghhiah, Vol. 2, Qom, Eslami Publications. (in Arabic)
Matini Daftari, Ahmad (2002). Civil and Commercial Procedure by Mahmoud Tagh Dareh and Naghi Ghahremanpour, Tehran, Majd Publications. (in Persain)
Mazandarani, Esmaeil (1990). Jurisprudential Treaties, Vol. 1, Mohaghegh: Seyed Mehdi Rajaei, Qom, Darolketab Aleslami Publications. (in Arabic)
Mohseni, Hassan (2012). Civil Procedure of France, Vol. 1, Tehran, Enteshar Publications. (in Persain)
Mohseni, Hassan (2012). “The Concept of Judicial Authority in Iranian Judicial System”, Legal Journal of the Department of Justice, Issues 79, pp. 99-123. (in Persain)
Mousavi-Ardebili, Seyed Abdolkarim (2002). Jurisprudence, Vol. 2, Bina. (in Persain)
Nahreini, Fereidoun (2014). Civil Procedure, Vol. 1, Tehran, Ganjedanesh Publications. (in Persain)
Nahreini, Fereidoun (2015). Nature and Effects of Contract Cancellation in Iranian Law, Tehran, Ganjedanesh Publications. (in Persain)
Nahreini, Feridoun (2018). Stability of Court Judgment Enforcement, Tehran, Ganjedanesh Publications. (in Persain)
Nahreini, Feridoun (2019). Civil Procedure, Vol. 2, Tehran, Ganjedanesh Publications. (in Persain)
Piketty, Thomas (2014). Distributive justice versus commutative justice 70¸ paris: seuil¸ 2013. English edition: Capital in the 21st century¸ Cambridge (Mass)¸ Harvard university press.
Rafiei¸ Mohammad-Taqi (1394). Majd Comprehensive Law Dictionary¸ Tehran¸ Majd.
Researchers of Studies and Research Office of Supreme Court of Law (1997). Negotiations and Decisions of United Chambers of Supreme Court in 1995, Tehran, Studies and Research Office of Supreme Court of Law. (in Persain)
Ross Zucker (2004). Democratic distributive justice¸ Cambridge university press¸ www.Cambridge.org.
Shams, Abdollah (2014). Advanced Civil Procedure, Vol. 1, Tehran, Derak Publications. (in Persain)
Sobhani, Seyed Jafar (1997). Judgment and Testimony in Divine Islamic Theology, Vol. 1, Qom, Imam Sadiq Institute Publications. (in Arabic)
Stephen, M. Gerlis (2001). County Court procedure¸ London Sydney¸ Cavendish publishing Limited¸ 3rd edition.
Tabatabaei, Seyed Alibenmohammad (1997). An Inferential Approach to Rules Research, By Mohammad Bahrehmand et al., Vol. 15, Qom, Alolbait Publications. (in Arabic)
Tousi, Aboujafar (1967). An Exegesis of Imamate Jurisprudence, By Seyed Mohamamd-Taghi Kashfi, Vol. 8, Tehran, amaktabolmortazavieh Eahyaelasareljafariah Publications. (in Arabic)
Wright, Richard (2000). The principles of justice: justice is the end of government, It is the end of civil society, notre Dame law Review wright¸ 75 notre Dame L. Rev. http://heinonline.Org.
 
Private Law
Volume 18, Issue 1
Spring & Summer
April 2021
Pages 1-20

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics